Category Archives: Canton Asylum for Insane Indians

Canton Asylum for Insane Indians in South Dakota was also known as Hiawatha. It opened in December 1902 and closed in 1934 after charges of neglect and abuse were validated. Dr. Harry Reid Hummer and Oscar Sherman Gifford were its only two superintendents. Its only patients were Native Americans, typically called Indians. It was the only federal insane asylum created solely for an ethnic group and served only Indians.

Pale Faces and Insanity

A Klickitat Brave, 1899, couresty Library of Congress

A Klickitat Brave, 1899, courtesy Library of Congress

In 1906, Major Charles E. Woodruff, of the Army Medical Corps, wrote an article about nervous disorders and complexion. He believed that excessive exposure to light was responsible for much “nervous damage” to blonds, who didn’t have enough pigmentation to protect themselves in a sunny climate. Proof of this lay in the fact that neurasthenia was more prevalent in the South than in the North.

According to Woodruff, insanity probably followed the same rule. He asserted that “in every part of the world statistics show that the greatest number of cases occur in or near our lightest months–May, June, and July.”

Well-pigmented people, however, were much safer, and didn’t suffer from insanity to the same degree as the “less protected types.” He said that people with dark hair, brown eyes, and olive or brown skin, could “evidently stand mental and nervous strains which blonds cannot endure….”

Woodruff’s beliefs were in direct opposition to those who believed Indians had a high prevalence of insanity because of their exposure to civilization.

Hospital for the Insane of the Army and Navy and the District of Columbia, courtesy Library of Congress

Hospital for the Insane of the Army and Navy and the District of Columbia, courtesy Library of Congress

________________________________________________________

Those Crazy Kids

Harry Cherkos, Feeble-Minded Child, Selling Papers, 1910, courtesy Library of Congress

Harry Cherkos, Feeble-Minded Child, Selling Papers, 1910, courtesy Library of Congress

Twentieth-century psychiatry embraced many conditions as madness, including epilepsy, alcoholism, and melancholia (what we now call depression). Early psychiatrists, called alienists at the time,  did not hesitate to stick an “insanity” label on a host of conditions, nor did they excuse any member of society.

Dr. John H.W. Rhein began a 1915 article in the American Journal of Insanity by discussing insanity in children. He stated that few children were in asylums because it was easier to treat them at home. The youngest case of insanity in children (on record) was nine months, said Dr. Rhein. Of 39 cases he had personally studied, five were in 5-7 year-olds.

Neurotic and Epileptic Child, courtesy Library of Congress

Neurotic and Epileptic Child, courtesy Library of Congress

Here is a typical case: Female, age 5. “After being threatened with being shut up in a closet and having heard tales of dark places where witches live and the like, was very much frightened…and for months thereafter raved and muttered about hobgoblins. When she recovered she was very much changed.”

A Case of Paralysis in an Insane Child, 1899, courtesy National Institutes of Health

A Case of Paralysis in an Insane Child, 1899, courtesy National Institutes of Health

________________________________________________________

Prohibiting Drinking

Demon Rum

Demon Rum

Prohibition did not go into effect in the U.S. until 1920, but the government was concerned early on with alcohol consumption by Indians. Some Indians groups (such as the Apaches) had used alcohol ceremonially before European contact, but after being introduced to it by traders and explorers, developed a liking for rum and other distilled spirits.

Traders, especially, liked to use alcohol when they dealt with Indians. Rum was something that Indians couldn’t make, but wanted, and it impaired their judgment during the subsequent trading. Because Indians were not used to drinking and were often prodded to consume too much, they frequently overindulged.

Traders Plying Alcohol
Traders Plying Alcohol

In 1832, a law was passed against giving “ardent spirits” to Indians, but the damage had already been done. Some Indians had developed a craving for alcohol, and greedy profiteers were willing to sell it to them. In 1910, Congress appropriated $60,000 ($1,400,000 today) for the suppression of “the liquor traffic among the Indians.”

Sign from 1919

Sign from 1919

________________________________________________________

Progress, Of Sorts

Indian Children on Flathead Reservation, 1907, courtesy Library of Congress

Indian Children on Flathead Reservation, 1907, courtesy Library of Congress

1910, this first decade of the new century, came in the middle of the Progressive Era. Reformers fought to limit child labor, break up monopolies, and help working men earn a fair wage.

The Indian Bureau tried to make a few strides, as well. It began inspecting homes on reservations, beginning with the White Earth Reservation in Minnesota.* Two special physicians visited more than 200 homes and examined 1,266 people. Of this number, 690 had trachoma and 164 had some form of tuberculosis. This dismaying state of affairs undoubtedly played out on most other reservations.

The Indian Bureau’s medical supervisor pushed to have schools inspected for sanitation, hygiene, and ventilation. Three reservations with a high number of day schools (Cheyenne River, Pine Ridge, and Rosebud) had a physician assigned to them. He made regular visits to check on the health of pupils and inspect the schools.

Indian Schoolchildren, Mt. Pleasant, MI

Indian Schoolchildren, Mt. Pleasant, MI

*Statistics are taken from the 1910 “Report of the Commissioner of Indian Affairs to the Secretary of the Interior.” (Fiscal year ending June 30, 1910).

Indian Children, Mescalero Reservation, N.M., circa 1936, courtesty Library of Congress

Indian Children, Mescalero Reservation, N.M., circa 1936, courtesty Library of Congress

________________________________________________________

A Superior Institution

St. Elizabeths, circa 1909, courtesy Library of Congress

St. Elizabeths, circa 1909, courtesy Library of Congress

The Canton Asylum for Insane Indians had little beyond fresh air and exercise to offer its patients. Superintendents allowed a little beadwork and craft-making to occupy patients’ time, along with field work and housekeeping for the able-bodied patients. It had no hospital in 1910, nor means of quarantining patients effectively.

St. Elizabeths had a training school for nurses, quarantine rooms, and a full hospital where operations ranging from appendectomies to hysterectomies were performed. The dental department performed extractions and cleanings for patients, and created false teeth for them.

Most tellingly, the psychiatric department conducted research and published its work in professional journals, like the American Journal of Insanity. It conducted additional research through its pathology laboratory, conducting autopsies and studying tissue samples to understand the changes disease caused in the body.

St. Elizabeths was a psychiatric and teaching hospital, while the Canton Asylum for Insane Indians was merely a warehouse.

St. Elizabeths Hydroptherapy Patients, courtesy Library of Congress

St. Elizabeths Hydrotherapy Patients, courtesy Library of Congress

________________________________________________________

Back In the City

Dr. William A. White, Superintendent of St. Elizabeths, courtesy Library of Congress

Dr. William A. White, Superintendent of St. Elizabeths, courtesy Library of Congress

St. Elizabeths cannot really be compared to the Canton Asylum for Insane Indians. Except for the fact that both institutions were run by the federal government, they were as different as night and day. St. Elizabeths was a huge institution, with over 2,700 patients in 1909; it required its own power plant. The institution had almost ten times the number of cattle (50) as the Canton Asylum, and enough poultry to require a hennery.

In common with its sister asylum, St. Elizabeths was often overcrowded. Because its DC location was closer to the center of power, however, superintendents could more easily make their case for additional money and facilities. St. Elizabeths housed (for the most part) soldiers and sailors, who had more public sympathy than Canton’s Indians.

Government Hospital for the Insane

Government Hospital for the Insane

________________________________________________________

Land and People

Canton Asylum for Insane Indians

Canton Asylum for Insane Indians

Inspector James McLaughlin’s report (see 9/30/10 post) is especially interesting when one compares the emphasis on the Canton Asylum for Insane Indians’ facilities, with the comfort of its patients. Besides the substantial buildings he noted, McLaughlin also mentioned that the asylum had 100 acres of land.

This acreage had been purchased for $30.00/acre and in 1910 was worth about $100/acre. About half of it was used to grow grain for the asylum’s cattle, as well as vegetables for the patients. The rest of the land was meadow and pasture, which allowed grazing in the summer and forage in the winter, for cattle and horses.

Pasture Land Near Castle Creek, S.D., courtesy U.S. Geographical Survey

Pasture Land Near Castle Creek, S.D., courtesy U.S. Geographical Survey

The building had been designed for 48 patients, and held 61 at the time of McLaughlin’s visit (September, 1910). There was no hospital, and only three rooms where patients with a communicable disease could be isolated. The septic system didn’t work, and drained raw sewage onto the grounds. McLaughlin said that the problem needed to be addressed immediately…not for the health of the patients, but to avoid trouble with the county commissioners.

Canton, SD High School, 1919

Canton, SD High School, 1919

________________________________________________________

Living the Life

Example of Electric Light Lamps, courtesy Early Office Museum

Example of Electric Light Lamps, courtesy Early Office Museum

Many insane asylums were huge institutions filled with hundreds of patients. This was never true of the Canton Asylum for Insane Indians, which seldom housed more than 90 patients at its most crowded.

Though the facility couldn’t boast too much about its size, its superintendents usually pointed with pride to its physical features. In 1910, inspector James McLaughlin noted that Canton Asylum had eighteen buildings, including its barns, sheds, corn cribs, and graneries.

The main building was two stories tall, with a jasper granite stone foundation. A basement ran underneath the entire building; it had a cement floor and  brick partition walls. The asylum also had a large attic, which had been divided into compartments but was not finished. These rooms were used for storage and for drying clothes during bad weather.

The two stories were each 11 feet high, which probably helped give it a spacious feeling. There were 120 electric-light lamps, a wonderful amenity for that time and place. To most visitors, the asylum looked both beautiful and well-functioning.

________________________________________________________

Picturing Insanity

Hospital Patient

Hospital Patient

Patients in insane asylums had few rights, and certainly little right to privacy. Public tours of insane asylums were common in the nineteen and early twentieth centuries, and few professionals seemed to find these tours insensitive. Doctors, themselves, often used patient histories in their lectures, though they didn’t usually divulge their patients’ identities.

Patients were often photographed. Some snapshots were taken by visitors to asylums, but others were taken by professional photographers for a variety of reasons (to illustrate newspaper accounts or academic material, for example). It is highly unlikely that these photographs were taken with informed consent by either patients or their families.

Glore Patients Out For a Stroll, 1902, courtesy Glore Psychiatric Museum

Glore Patients Out For a Stroll, 1902, courtesy Glore Psychiatric Museum

________________________________________________________

How Crazy Were Indians?

Medicine Man Administering to a Patient, courtesy Library of Congress

Medicine Man Administering to a Patient, courtesy Library of Congress

Native Americans recognized mental illness, and had several descriptive names for different conditions. The Navajos called tremors and seizures “moth madness,” which was said to be caused by sibling incest. Some tribes considered violent mania to be the result of the evil spirit, windigo, which could possess someone’s body and eat souls.

Sometimes, Native Americans attributed insanity to the influence of an evil charm or to a enemy’s potion. Along with that belief was the counter-belief that a stronger charm or potion would effect a cure.

Ironically, an article in the October 1903 issue of the American Journal of Insanity (discussing a study of 7,600 cases of insanity in Connecticut over 32 years) noted that Native Americans had the lowest incidence of insanity in the population. This finding was backed up in a number of books of the period, in which missionaries and others who frequently traveled among a variety of tribes, declared that they had never seen any insane Indians.

Skull To Keep Evil Spirits Away, Montana, courtesy Library of Congress

Skull To Keep Evil Spirits Away, Montana, courtesy Library of Congress

Hupa Shaman, 1923, courtesy Library of Congress

Hupa Shaman, 1923, courtesy Library of Congress

________________________________________________________