Category Archives: Canton Asylum for Insane Indians

Canton Asylum for Insane Indians in South Dakota was also known as Hiawatha. It opened in December 1902 and closed in 1934 after charges of neglect and abuse were validated. Dr. Harry Reid Hummer and Oscar Sherman Gifford were its only two superintendents. Its only patients were Native Americans, typically called Indians. It was the only federal insane asylum created solely for an ethnic group and served only Indians.

Saving Money at the Insane Asylum

Patients Working in Laundry Room at Texas State Lunatic Asylum, 1898

Patients Working in Laundry Room at Texas State Lunatic Asylum, 1898

Most insane asylums tried to use patient labor as a way of holding down costs, or as a sort of occupational therapy. At the Canton Asylum for Insane Indians, Dr. Harry Hummer had a real mission to hold down expenses, since he knew that his small facility didn’t have the economies of scale that larger institutions did.

Female patients generally worked on household tasks, like sewing and laundry. Susan Wishecoby, an epileptic patient, wrote about scrubbing the floors, and other women complained about the amount of work they had to do. Men usually worked in the gardens or helped with livestock. Dr. Hummer couldn’t actually force patients to work, but many did because it helped them pass the time. They may have also wanted to please the attendants or Dr. Hummer by appearing cooperative.

Patients Sewing at the Cherokee State Hospital for the Insane, early 1900s

Patients Sewing at the Cherokee State Hospital for the Insane, early 1900s

Patients Picking Cotton at Alabama Insane Hospital

Patients Picking Cotton at Alabama Insane Hospital

________________________________________________________________

The BIA Field Matron Program

Field Matron, Arizona

Field Matron, Arizona

Between 1890 and 1938, the Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA) employed women as Field Matrons. Their job was to go into Native American homes to teach domestic science (sewing, cooking, hygiene, etc.) according to middle-class white standards. This was a relatively peaceful way for the BIA to continue its work of assimilating Indians into white culture; they destroyed Indians’ old habits and ways of doing things and replaced them with the white man’s way.

Matrons taught mainly on reservations, since the feeling was that Indians still living in teepees or roaming the land wouldn’t be able to take advantage of the matrons’ lessons. Besides sewing and other practical accomplishments, matrons taught Indian women to decorate their homes, care for their animals and children like whites, and teach their children sports and Anglo games. Commissioner of Indian Affairs Cato Sells urged matrons to stress the importance of legal marriage to Indians, and to try to increase their desire for material goods so that lazy Indians would work harder to provide them.

Typical Indian Home (Flathead Reservation, 1909), courtesy Library of Congress

Typical Indian Home (Flathead Reservation, 1909), courtesy Library of Congress

Interior of Teepee (1905-1907?), courtesy Library of Congress

Interior of Teepee (1905-1907?), courtesy Library of Congress

Field matrons were charged with “civilizing” Indians in their own homes. Though heavy-handed, it was preferable to tearing families apart and sending children away as the BIA’s boarding school program did. Though the BIA applauded their efforts, eventually devastating health problems among Indians prompted the agency to replace field matrons with nurses.

_______________________________________________________________

A Range of Responsibilities

Hubert Work (center), 1928, courtesy Library of Congress

Hubert Work (center), 1928, courtesy Library of Congress

The Indian Service, or later, Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA) fell under the department of the Interior. The Interior department had a wide range of responsibilities, including the provision of medical services for various groups under its control.

In 1927, Secretary of the Interior, Hubert Work, tried to show the range of  just the Interior’s medical services:

— It had a floating hospital on the Yukon in Alaska (a territory at the time) and supported territorial Boards of Health in Alaska and Hawaii.

— It safeguarded the health of visitors within the National Park system.

— Trained nurses and field matrons went to remote areas of the country, teaching hygiene and sanitation.

— The department’s Geological Survey investigated ground water supplies.

— Its Bureau of Education investigated the status of physical education and hygiene in colleges and reported on the health of teachers

— Through its Bureau of Pensions, conducted physical exams and medical rating boards for veterans.

The department supported more than 100 hospitals providing over 2 million days of hospital care; the Indian Bureau maintained 91 of them. More than 30,000 Indian patients were treated in these hospitals in fiscal year 1926.

BIA Health Officer

BIA Health Officer

Tulalip Hospital, Tulalip Indian Reservation, 1910, courtesy Library of Congress

Tulalip Hospital, Tulalip Indian Reservation, 1910, courtesy Library of Congress

________________________________________________________

Oh, To Be a Woman

American Woman and Her Political Peers, 1893, couresty Library of Congress

American Woman and Her Political Peers, 1893, courtesy Library of Congress

Women could contract pellagra or masturbate (see last two posts) and become insane, but they were thought to have specific weaknesses that made them susceptible to insanity.

An acute illness of the uterus or ovaries could cause insanity, said Dr. Alexander J.C. Skene in 1889, as could frequent childbearing. Other physicians believed that women could become insane through mistreatment, poverty, too many household cares, grief, or fear. Even the tight-lacing of corsets could lead to insanity. Half the women brought to the Athens Lunatic Asylum in its first three years were insane because of the change of life or “menstrual derangements.”

There was a wide-held belief that women were the weaker sex–physically, emotionally, and intellectually. Because women’s brains weighed less than men’s, alienists thought that they were less developed. Women were therefore more susceptible to mental problems. Anything that might tax a woman’s brain could contribute to insanity; some experts estimated that education drained away about 20% of a woman’s “vital energy.”

Example of Tight Corset

Example of Tight Corset

Bedrest for Hysteria

Bedrest for Hysteria

________________________________________________________

Sex and the Unbalanced Mind

Prof. William H. Walling, A.M., M.D.

Prof. William H. Walling, A.M., M.D.

Alienists (early mental illness specialists) thought that over-excitement or over-stimulation of all kinds could cause insanity. Sexual matters were not exempt, though most of alienists’ focus was on masturbation, also called onanism. In his 1904 book, Sexology, Dr. William H. Walling told how masturbation caused males to lose their memory and intelligence until they could scarcely answer the simplest of questions.

Walling quotes another physician who related the case of a child who contracted the habit (of masturbation) at the age of five years: “who, in spite of all that could be done, died at sixteen, having lost his reason at eleven.” It was Walling’s opinion that all masturbators would die the most horrible of deaths.

Dr. Walling had a strict view about sexual matters: he made it clear that intercourse was only for the purpose of having children. During pregnancy, when “the legitimate object of the sexual act is absent,” intercourse could lead to deformed, idiotic, undeveloped infants, or what he called “monstrosities.”

Walling's Book, Sexology

Walling's Book, Sexology

Anti-masturbation Device, courtesy Science Museum, London Science and Society Picture Library

Anti-masturbation Device, courtesy Science Museum, London Science and Society Picture Library

________________________________________________________

Unusual Causes of Insanity

Pellagra Dermatitis

Pellagra Dermatitis

Pellagra is a disease caused by a niacin (B-vitamin) deficiency, lack of tryptophan (an amino acid) in the diet, or a failure to absorb these nutrients. Pellagra is common in parts of the world where people have a lot of corn in their diet. In the U.S., it was almost epidemic among the Southern poor who ate a diet high in corn, molasses, and fat-back.

Pellagra was defined as a specific disease around the turn of the 20th century. Doctors diagnosed it by classic symptoms like dermatitis, diarrhea, and…dementia which frequently took the form of stupor and melancholy. For years, pellagra was thought to cause insanity, and many victims were sent to asylums as a result. Some patients may have recovered once their diets became less corn-based, but diets were often poor in asylums.

Dr. John Goldberger

Dr. John Goldberger

During the winter of 1913-1914, Surgeon General Rupert Blue appointed an epidemiologist named John Goldberger to conduct pellagra studies. Goldberger thought there might be a nutritional component, since staff at insane asylums rarely developed pellagra, while patients did. (Staff ate more nutritious food, in general). He discovered that in one Georgia asylum, nearly 8% of patients developed pellagra after they were admitted.

Dr. Goldberger is credited with discovering the nutritional basis of pellagra, but he was not able to name the specific component (niacin) responsible. In 1937, a chemist named Conrad A. Elvehjem discovered that nicotinic acid could cure black tongue (a symptom of pellagra) in dogs; after that treatment for pellagra became readily available.

________________________________________________________

Hydrotherapy

Continuous Bath, Life Photograph

Continuous Bath, Life Photograph

The plunge bath, douche bath, continuous bath, needle bath, and so on, fell under hydrotherapy treatment. In theory, the treatment should have been effective and fairly humane. Warm, soothing baths would help patients sleep, while a plunge bath, using water at temperatures between 45-70 degrees, might shock a violent patient into settling down. Though uncomfortable, such a treatment was preferable to being wrestled to the ground or restrained.

Hydrotherapy Wrapping, St. Elizabeths, courtesy National Archives

Hydrotherapy Wrapping, St. Elizabeths, courtesy National Archives

Even at the best of times, hydrotherapy tended to be uncomfortable. Many doctors thought cold water treatment was superior to warm, and believed treatments should be administered in the morning just as the patient arose. Many medical people believed that warm baths opened up the pores so that a person could catch cold more easily.

Plunge baths and other cold water hydrotherapy were  believed to be invigorating for patients, though other doctors thought it absurd to think that any person–sick or well–would enjoy emerging from a warm bed in order to plunge into a cold bath. Unfortunately, patients had no say in the matter and had to live with whichever theory their own doctor adhered to.

Hydrotherapy Apparatus

Hydrotherapy Apparatus

________________________________________________________

Punishing the Insane

Douche Bath in Pennsylvania Hospital for the Insane, 1868, courtesy cournellpsychiatry.org

Douche Bath in Pennsylvania Hospital for the Insane, 1868, courtesy cournellpsychiatry.org

Some asylum superintendents treated their patients like naughty children or criminals, imposing punishment upon those who were unruly or uncooperative.

Doctors forced patients to take hyoscyamine (an alkaloid found in henbane that has a very bitter, nasty taste) or to drink disgusting concoctions. Another popular punishment was the plunge bath, in which patients were repeatedly dunked in ice-cold water.

Hyoscyamine (Henbane)

Hyoscyamine (Henbane)

Patients who were able to work, but refused to do so, were especially irritating. Doctors might try to humiliate or degrade them by forcing these patients to wear ragged clothes, or by cutting their hair off.

Other doctors noted that these punishments seldom worked, and called for humane treatment. In their opinion, the insanity itself was the cause of a patient’s misbehavior. These doctors felt it was pointless to punish someone who couldn’t control his behavior or had lost his moral sense through the disease of insanity.

Surprise Bath, courtesy cornellpsychiatry.org

Surprise Bath, courtesy cornellpsychiatry.org

________________________________________________________

Food as Punishment

Dr. Paul Eugen Bleuler

Dr. Paul Eugen Bleuler

Force-feeding, though it may have had its place in a time when IV supplementation did not exist, was both painful and notoriously brutal. Many patients felt that it was used far too often as a punishment for various stubborn behaviors.

The notion of being forced to eat would agitate many patients, and his or her forcible subjugation by three or more attendants would only increase the patient’s fear and hysteria. Inserting a tube down someone’s throat or nose is a delicate operation at best, and would be extremely painful, and even injurious, to a patient under these circumstances.

Dr. Paul Eugen Bleuler used force-feeding to “prove” that a female patient under his care had only been been pretending insanity. He bragged that “after one tube-feeding, there was a sudden cure.” It is more likely that the pain temporarily jolted the patient out of a confused state.

________________________________________________________

Tube Feeding

Reporter on Force-Feeding, 1914

Reporter on Force-Feeding, 1914

Food mattered to patients, of course; eating was often one of the few pleasures of the day. Whether or not the food was palatable, patients who ate willingly were far better off than those who refused to take in an adequate amount of food. Below is a shortened description of involuntary feeding, from an article that appeared in an 1872 issue of The British Medical Journal:

An attendant kneels at the head of the bedstead, with a knee on each side of the patient’s head. Two other attendants pass a sheet over the patient and draw it tightly. Each one kneels on the sheet to keep it in place, then holds one of the patient’s arms. After this immobilization, the physician opens the patient’s mouth with a screw-gag,  inserts about 18 inches of tube down the patient’s esophagus, then injects food into the tube with a stomach pump.

Antique Screw-Gag

Antique Screw-Gag

Force-feeding a Suffragette

Force-feeding a Suffragette

This article described another method in which the physician could forgo the stomach pump, and instead, simply pour the food into a funnel that emptied into the tube. The force of gravity would take the food to the stomach.

________________________________________________________