Inmates at the Imbecile Asylum, Burlington NJ, circa 1886, courtesy National Library of Medicine, Image A019401

Men and women who were not insane could be labeled as such when authorities viewed their actions through inappropriate cultural filters that did not allow for deviations in behavior due to a non-Anglo upbringing. (See last two posts.) Immigrants and Native Americans were particularly vulnerable to this type of misdiagnosis, but the medical community’s enthusiasm for labeling put many other people at risk for possible imprisonment. People who seemed “slow” or had different ways of learning also risked labeling; feeble-minded, moron, or idiot were common terms for those who seemed to lack intelligence.

Society often wanted to segregate people they considered of lesser intelligence from the mainstream. Many people feared that those with lesser intelligence would pass on that undesirable trait to their children if they were allowed to marry “normal” partners. Some people feared that the unscrupulous would prey on these weaker members of society unless they were in an institution and under the care of  its staff. Most states set aside special homes for citizens they deemed unable to care for themselves due to a lack of intelligence. Unlike insanity, most authorities did not consider it possible to recover from feeble-mindedness or idiocy. Dismissal to a home designed to care for minds of lesser ability was usually a true life sentence.

Caning Chairs at a Massachusetts School for the Feeble-Minded, 1903, courtesy Harvard Art Museums

Laundry Class in Massachusetts Home for the Feeble-Minded, 1903, courtesy Harvard Art Museums



2 thoughts on “Labels

  1. Carla Joinson Post author

    These surnames do not appear for patients at the Canton Asylum for Insane Indians, which was an asylum strictly for American Indians. If you think an ancestor was possibly a patient in a New Jersey-area institution, you would need to do an internet search to discover any good possibilities and then try to find a patient roster. Unfortunately, many patient records have been destroyed over the years, or are closed for HIPPA (medical privacy) reasons; the best course of action is to contact the hospital if it is still open. Depending on what you actually want to know, they may be able to help. Also, if an ancestor was a patient at an institution, that fact may show up in a census record.

  2. Wallace Dennison

    Were their any Jackson Whites in the hospitals. We were the subject of the Vineland Training School, NJ . An Unpublished study was written in 1911, The JAckson Whites a Study of Racial Degeneracy. Some of the Surnames were. Defreese, Degroat, Dennison, Mann, Suffern, Vandunk.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *