Author Archives: Carla Joinson

Industrialization and Mental Illness

George Beard

George Beard

Americans may have enjoyed many of the new inventions and opportunities the dawning industrial age offered, but many were also thrown off balance by the increasingly fast pace of the late 1800s.

Dr. George Beard noticed that Americans were having difficulty coping with life as new forms of transportation, communication, and automation made their way into society. He tried to make sense of the physical symptoms cropping up in far too many ordinary, upper and middle-class people, and determined that they were caused by an “exhaustion of the nervous system.” He termed the syndrome neurasthenia.

Beard's Book on American Mental Illness

Beard’s Book on American Mental Illnes

Though Beard’s observations were quite astute to some degree, he also perpetuated some stereotypes. He believed that “civilization” and its higher demands led to certain nervous conditions and physical complaints: “The savage can usually see well; myopia is a measure of civilization.”

Likewise, American women, who were given the opportunity to socialize more easily than women in other countries, developed their “cerebral activity” more quickly. This, in turn, influenced their physical development, with the end result that American women were typically more beautiful and expressive than women in other countries.

 

Americans Sought Help for Nervous Diseases

Americans Sought Help for Nervous Diseases

Change in the Air

A Literary Reminder of a Fading West

A Literary Reminder of a Fading West

Though 1903 continued in the same difficult pattern and lifestyle for most Americans (see last post), the year also saw many exciting changes. The Canton Asylum for Insane Indians, with its modern lighting and plumbing, reflected the wave of innovation and invention rippling throughout the country.

From 1900 – 1903:

  • Henry Ford founded Ford Motor Company.
  • Germans invented the zeppelin airship.
  • Orville Wright made his first flight on the Wright Flyer.
  • Guglielmo Marconi completed the first two-way wireless message 
  • Crayons were invented.
  • Owen Wister wrote The Virginian.
Young Polish Boy, a Migrant Worker, Picking Berries in Maryland, courtesy National Archives

Young Polish Boy, a Migrant Worker, Picking Berries in Maryland, courtesy National Archives

 

Industrialization had come to the country, even though the majority of the population still lived in rural areas. Men, women, and children abandoned farms and sought the factory work which mechanical innovation made available.

Along with it came the ills of modern society and some new psychological problems. But, not to fear, for alienists were ready and willing to meet the challenges of the new era.

 

 

Count Ferdinand Von Zeppelin Invented His Namesake Dirigible

Count Ferdinand Von Zeppelin Invented His Namesake Dirigible

 

New Century, Old Ways

New York Street Scene, 1903

New York Street Scene, 1903

Life was difficult around the turn of the twentieth century. A simple scratch or sore throat that developed into strep could still cause death since there were no effective antibiotics, most homes had no indoor plumbing, and heating fuel was dirty and inconvenient.

Feeding Chickens in Montana, 1908

Feeding Chickens in Montana, 1908

Though most women no longer had to weave their own cloth, many were still cutting out patterns and sewing their family’s clothes.

 

Farming was labor-intensive, with a lot of human-power to supplement whatever farm animals were available for plowing, planting, and other tasks. Canning food for the winter was hot, exhausting, and seemingly endless when the crops came in and food had to be processed right away.

Farm House in Nebraska, 1903, courtesy Library of Congress

Farm House in Nebraska, 1903, courtesy Library of Congress

It is little wonder that the townspeople in Canton, South Dakota were so proud and impressed with the new Canton Asylum for Insane Indians,with its electric lights and indoor plumbing. (The asylum had range toilets; these flushed at intervals rather than after each individual use, but were still a great convenience.)

In an age when even very young children worked hard on farms or in dangerous factory and mining jobs, the public could feel gratified that an institution existed which could provide food, shelter, and medical care to people who were struggling to get through life.

 

 

Time Matters

Charles Eastman, 1897, courtesy Smithsonian Institution

Charles Eastman, 1897, courtesy Smithsonian Institution

The world was truly a different place when the Canton Asylum for Insane Indians first opened on the last day of 1902. Even something as simple as clothing was remarkably different from what we typically see and wear today. Men dressed far more formally and women were tied down (and sometimes literally weighted down) with voluminous dresses and hats. Continue reading

How to Help

Occupational Therapy, Toy Making in WWI-Era Psychiatric Hospital, courtesy Otis Historical Archives, National Museum of Health and Medicine

Occupational Therapy, Toy Making in WWI-Era Psychiatric Hospital, courtesy Otis Historical Archives, National Museum of Health and Medicine

Dr. Harry Hummer, superintendent of the Canton Asylum for Insane Indians, was not inclined to an active, hands-on approach to helping his patients overcome mental illness. In addition to his own weakness in this area, he may have found it nearly impossible to apply his book knowledge to real-life situations at the asylum. Continue reading

Keeping Up

Outlines of Psychiatry

Outlines of Psychiatry

Like most people, Dr. Harry Hummer, superintendent of the Canton Asylum for Insane Indians, had a number of contradictory traits. Though he was accused of poor record-keeping on his patients and of a failure to institute any kind of mental health plan for them, he was clearly interested in maintaining expertise in his field. Continue reading

And One Step Backward

Sioux Indian Women Receiving Rations, Pine Ridge Reservation, 1891, courtesy Library of Congress

Sioux Indian Women Receiving Rations, Pine Ridge Reservation, 1891, courtesy Library of Congress

By the early 1920s, some of the indifference to Native Americans’ cultural values had lessened.

However, even if  a government official occasionally saw positive traits in native peoples or respected their need for cultural wholeness, his viewpoint could be buried in a continued avalanche of popular sentimentality and/or naivete that perpetuated stereotypes and fed unrealistic daydreams about the status of Native Americans. Continue reading

Tiny Steps

ield Matron and Assistants, 1905

Field Matron and Assistants, 1905

Most Europeans settlers believed that their respective cultures were superior to Native American ones, and set about imposing their own ideas upon native peoples as soon as they were able to do so. Continue reading

Paperwork

Record of Patients at St. Louis Insane Asylum, 1886

Record of Patients at St. Louis Insane Asylum, 1886

Running an insane asylum involved a great deal of administrative work, and it is no wonder that some records were not as meticulous as inspectors and latter-day researchers would have liked.

Dr. Harry Hummer, superintendent of the Canton Asylum for Insane Indians, was often accused of poor-record keeping. However, not all of his records were badly kept; the problem lay in where he chose to put his efforts. A February, 1927 journal voucher lists 30 patients along with small sums spent on their behalf. These sums ranged from a few dollars to fifteen cents, yet Dr. Hummer kept track of them for reimbursement purposes.

Conversely, he spent almost no time updating patient medical records during the asylum’s later years; he left that task to his attendants who often jotted repetitive, meaningless updates that were useless for diagnostic purposes. Perhaps Dr. Hummer put his energy only into those tasks he thought would benefit himself and contribute to the efficiency of the asylum.

Patient Record From Nineteenth Century

Patient Record From Nineteenth Century

 

Many asylums have not retained all their patient records (or have deliberately destroyed them), so Canton Asylum’s incomplete patient records does not present an unusual situation. One inadvertent benefit to Hummer’s attention to detail in certain areas is that it is at least possible to cull patient names from these types of documents.

Death Certificate From Western State Hospital

Death Certificate From Western State Hospital

 

By going through vouchers and reports, researchers can fill in gaps that might exist in the records they would prefer to have, or uncover tidbits of information that present a clearer picture of  their subject matter. For instance, a payroll list from June 1923 shows that Dr. Hummer’s father, Levi, and his son, Harry Hummer, Jr. were employed at the asylum; additionally, a separate letter to the Indian Office that same month shows that Dr. Hummer’s other son, Francis, acted as an escort for patients coming to the asylum from Taos, New Mexico. It would certainly be interesting to speculate or do further research on the dynamics of this family employment.

 

Reports, Reports

Nurse and Patients at Fergus Falls State Hospital, 1900

Nurse and Patients at Fergus Falls State Hospital, 1900

With perhaps a very rare exception, all insane asylums were inspected on a reasonably regular basis, and inspectors visited the Canton Asylum for Insane Indians a number of times. Visits were usually routine, though the asylum received a number of special inspections brought on by complaints or allegations of misconduct that reached the Indian Office. Continue reading